Advanced
Teachers Question Teaching Alice Munro After Learning Sad News
July 16th, 2024
Alice Munro, a celebrated Canadian short story writer and Nobel Prize winner, has always been highly regarded in literary circles for her deep understanding of human nature, especially within her female characters. Her work has not only been taught in universities but has also gained her the affectionate moniker of "Saint Alice" due to the perceived moral guidance in her stories.
However, recent and disturbing revelations about Munro's personal life have cast a shadow over her esteemed literary career. Robert Lecker, a professor and expert on Munro's works, is now faced with an ethical dilemma—whether it is still appropriate to teach a graduate course on Munro's stories. His indecision stems from the heartbreaking admission by Munro's daughter, Andrea Skinner, that she was sexually assaulted by her stepfather, with Munro being aware and ultimately choosing to stay with him despite the abuse.
This news has shaken the literary world, prompting educators and institutions to reevaluate Munro's legacy. Western University, where Munro studied, is reassessing her ties to the institution, and the Alice Munro Chair in Creativity remains vacant as a consequence. Similarly, at Harvard University, authors Laura van den Berg and Neel Mukherjee are rethinking how to approach her work in their upcoming course on fiction writing.
The conflict within the academic community is palpable. Kellie Elrick, a student of Lecker's, finds herself wrestling with the discordant narratives of Munro as a gifted writer and as a mother who failed to protect her daughter. The discomfort extends to teaching and reading Munro's stories such as "Friend of My Youth," which will still be taught despite the unsettling context it now carries.
Both van den Berg and Mukherjee are confronted with the challenge of how to separate the art from the artist and whether such separation is feasible or ethically sound. Mukherjee admits to feeling conflicted, recognizing the horror of Munro's personal choices but also pondering if Munro's own struggles have infused her work with a deeper, albeit troubling, dimension.
This situation raises broader questions about the relationship between an artist's life and work, and whether it is possible—or even fair—to appreciate the former without being influenced by the latter, a dilemma that each individual must reconcile on their own.
AI isn't perfect, so some things may be inaccurate. We don't necessarily endorse the views or information you see here and provide it for language learning purposes only.
💭 Discussion Questions
1
. In what ways do the recent revelations about Alice Munro challenge the perception of her as 'Saint Alice' and the moral guidance found in her stories?2
. How can educators balance the inclusion of a writer's literary contributions with the consideration of their personal actions when deciding whether to teach their work?3
. What are the implications for a writer's legacy when details of their personal life conflict with the themes and values depicted in their work?📖 Vocabulary
🌐 Cultural context
Alice Munro is from Canada, a country known for its significant contributions to literature. Canadian culture places great value on academic and artistic achievements, often celebrating successful figures. The article touches on the moral complexities of evaluating an artist's work in light of their personal actions.
🧠 Further reading
AI literacy
Artificial Intelligence (AI) literacy is an essential set of proficiencies that allow people to effectively engage with AI technology. It is not just intended for AI experts, but rather for the broader community to grasp AI concepts, apply them in everyday situations, critically evaluate their implications, and navigate the AI landscape responsibly.
It's crucial for students in schools and colleges to become AI-literate as AI pervades various domains, from navigating self-driving cars to interacting with virtual assistants. Possessing an understanding of AI is not only important for practical purposes but also because it can greatly influence students' career opportunities in the future.
AI literacy interconnects with and builds upon other key literacies. Digital literacy provides a foundation for AI literacy, while scientific and computational insights enhance it. Moreover, data literacy closely aligns with the ability to handle AI, due to the significant role data plays in AI systems.
To become AI-literate, one should explore several core categories:
Firstly, one should gain a solid theoretical grasp of what AI is and how it operates. This includes a basic awareness of machine learning algorithms and recognizing the potential biases within AI systems. Familiarity with AI-infused technologies like cognitive systems, robotics, and machine learning is an essential part of this knowledge.
Furthermore, the practical side of AI literacy involves the hands-on ability to use and implement AI technologies.
By refining these competencies, individuals become equipped to participate thoughtfully and effectively in our increasingly AI-driven world.
Cultural impact of Taylor Swift
American artist Taylor Swift has had an extraordinary impact on the entertainment world through her music, personal brand, and contributions to society, an influence sometimes termed as the "Taylor Swift effect." Emerging onto the scene as a young country artist, she has since expanded into numerous musical styles, including pop, alternative rock, and indie folk.
As one of the most influential figures in contemporary culture, Swift's musical talent and business savvy have served as an inspiration to many. She is celebrated for her ability to consistently succeed both commercially and critically, nurturing a devoted fanbase while also challenging existing norms in the music industry.
Swift has been a driving force in the transformation of music distribution and consumption, particularly during the digital age. She has been vocal on social media about various issues in the music industry and beyond, advocating for artist rights, authentic creative ownership, and leading a resurgence in vinyl records.
Known for her massive economic influence and political clout, Swift has encouraged changes in the way music is recorded, streamed, and distributed, emphasizing the importance of artists maintaining control over their work. Her career has been marked by extraordinary sales across albums, digital platforms, streaming services, and concert tours, making her a defining figure in the music industry.
Beyond her commercial triumphs, Swift's work has attracted extensive analytical interest, becoming a subject of both media scrutiny and academic study. With this level of engagement across multiple fronts, she has earned distinctions for her advocacy, marketing expertise, innovative music videos, and record-setting performances on the road.
Nature versus nurture
The longstanding debate surrounding human behavior and development is epitomized by the concepts of 'nature versus nurture'. Nature encompasses the genetic makeup and biological aspects that a person inherits, whereas nurture involves the external factors and influences experienced after birth, including exposure, interactions, and learning.
Tracing its roots back to both the Elizabethan period and medieval French, the pairing of 'nature and nurture' has been an integral part of societal discourse for centuries. It was Francis Galton, a Victorian-era polymath known for pioneering eugenics and behavioral genetics, who brought the modern understanding of these terms to the forefront. Galton, influenced by the groundbreaking works of his relative Charles Darwin, explored how heredity and environment play roles in social progression.
There was a time, notably in the 20th century, when many scholars adopted the 'blank slate' view. This notion, initially proposed by philosopher John Locke in 1690, suggests that human beings are born without innate traits, and all behaviors are acquired solely through environmental influences. This perspective dominated much of psychological theory for decades.
However, the dichotomy between 'nature' proponents, who recognize the role of genetics, and 'nurture' advocates, focusing on environmental factors, has often been seen as overly simplistic. As research has advanced, it has become evident that both genetic and environmental factors intricately contribute to human development, leading to the conclusion that the pure 'blank slate' view is overly naive. The interplay between inherent predispositions and life experiences thus forms the crux of individual differences and developmental trajectories.